Immigration Attorney Blog
Adjustment of status · Fourth Circuit precedent

Adjustment in removal court: the Fourth Circuit clarifies the burden of proof

A published ruling concerns previously admitted people seeking adjustment in removal proceedings. Its reach and the applicant’s procedural position matter.

Which burden of proof applies? Fourth Circuit: Preponderance for previously admitted adjustment applicants in removal proceedings. Nivar Santana v. Blanche, November 2, 2026. Farhan Aryan and the firm crest.
Immigration law update · Law Firm of Farhan Aryan P.C.Download banner
KEY TAKEAWAY

For the previously admitted applicants covered by this Fourth Circuit ruling, admissibility is proved by a preponderance of the evidence. It does not guarantee adjustment.

The November 2 ruling

In Nivar Santana v. Blanche, No. 22-2114 (4th Cir. Nov. 2, 2026), a published opinion on remand from the Supreme Court, the court required a preponderance standard instead of clearly and beyond doubt for previously admitted applicants seeking adjustment as relief from removal.

The court treated Dakura’s contrary burden statement as dicta. It granted review and remanded; it did not decide that the applicant had proved admissibility or award a green card. The earlier appellate opinion had been vacated for reconsideration after Loper Bright.

Sources: [1]

Who can rely on this decision

Published Fourth Circuit holdings bind immigration courts and the BIA within that circuit, subject to controlling higher authority. In New York, a Fourth Circuit opinion is persuasive rather than binding: counsel must check the controlling Second Circuit law. This judicial decision is not a nationwide USCIS policy change.

The holding turns on prior admission and the posture of an adjustment request in removal proceedings. It should not be generalized to arriving applicants or everyone who entered without admission. No later modifying authority was identified in the targeted searches used for this article; mandate, rehearing and subsequent case-specific proceedings were not independently verified.

Sources: [1][2]

The standard does not replace the evidence

A burden of proof answers how convincing the showing must be. It does not supply a missing record or settle a disputed event. Our practical recommendation is to separate three questions for counsel: which standard governs, which facts are disputed, and what reliable evidence addresses them.

If an old employment or immigration form is causing concern, preserve the complete version you have. Identify who prepared it, who signed it, and what you personally remember. Do not change an old document or fill gaps with guesses. A clear account of what is known, unknown and supported helps counsel assess the issue.

Preparing for an individual review

Bring entry and admission records, prior applications, the disputed document, agency decisions and hearing notices. Include earlier explanations you gave about the same event. Consistency is easier to assess when counsel can see the complete history.

Ask how the court location and procedural posture affect the analysis before assuming that a favorable opinion elsewhere changes your case. Discuss any response or appeal deadline promptly. A consultation should focus on the documents and governing law that apply to you, rather than a prediction based on the headline.

SOURCES & FURTHER READING
  1. Fourth Circuit: Nivar Santana v. Blanche, No. 22-2114, published November 2, 2026 — official opinion
  2. EOIR: Sources of immigration law and authority of federal circuit decisions

Source materials were consulted for this original article. Links lead to external resources; later changes may affect the information discussed here.

Attorney Advertising. General information as of November 11, 2026; not legal advice or a prediction of results. Eligibility and strategy require review of your individual circumstances. Read our Legal Disclaimer.

WhatsApp