Immigration Attorney Blog
Reopening and U visa related relief · Published Seventh Circuit opinion

A reopening denial must address the request actually made

In Panton v. Blanche, the Seventh Circuit sent a case back after the BIA overlooked a tolling request and confused a U visa with a waiver. The ruling did not grant either benefit and is not controlling Second Circuit law.

Reopening: the reasons matter. Seventh Circuit remand; no visa or waiver granted. Panton v. Blanche, November 10, 2026. Farhan Aryan in his red shirt with the firm crest.
Immigration law update · Law Firm of Farhan Aryan P.C.Download banner
KEY TAKEAWAY

A remand requires the agency to reconsider with proper reasoning. It does not establish that a late motion will be accepted or that a visa, waiver or return to the United States will be approved.

The question the Board needed to answer

A delayed document can create more than a missing exhibit. If a removal case has already ended, the person may need to explain both why the new material matters and why it could not have been presented sooner. Those are separate issues, and the agency must address the requests actually put before it.

On November 10, 2026, the Seventh Circuit issued its published opinion in Panton v. Blanche, No. 25-2528. A former permanent resident sought reopening after receiving a delayed law-enforcement certification connected to a pending U visa petition. He argued that the delay justified equitable tolling of the usual 90-day reopening deadline and sought further consideration of an inadmissibility waiver.

The Board treated the motion as though only reopening on its own initiative remained available, despite the express tolling request. It also relied on USCIS’s authority to issue U visas without addressing the different waiver request, and did not address the request for discretionary closure. The court returned the case to the Board.

Sources: [1]

What the court left undecided

The court applied the principle that an agency decision is judged on the reasons the agency gave. New arguments offered by the government’s lawyer in court did not supply the missing agency analysis.

Panton did not receive a U visa, an inadmissibility waiver or permission to return to the United States through this decision. The opinion left substantial questions about the availability and scope of waiver authority unresolved. It also did not decide that equitable tolling must be granted. The Board must address the arguments on remand; the court did not require renewed consideration of reopening on the Board’s own initiative.

Sources: [1]

Why the location of a case matters

This is a published Seventh Circuit opinion, rather than the separate nonprecedential disposition in Panton’s earlier litigation. Published circuit law binds the agency within that circuit; decisions from another circuit may be persuasive. The fact that New York officials supplied the certification does not make this a Second Circuit ruling.

For New York clients, the applicable reopening standards and the authority of the particular adjudicator need an independent controlling-law analysis. The decision should not be used as a promise that any immigration judge can grant the same waiver request or that a pending U visa petition prevents removal. As of November 18, the official opinion reviewed remained the November 10 decision; later appellate or agency action may affect the analysis.

Sources: [1][2]

Build the timeline before choosing a filing

Keep dated copies of requests for certification, follow-up communications, responses and the final certification. Bring the removal decisions and evidence of when they were received. A clear chronology helps counsel assess delay, diligence and available procedures without having to reconstruct events from memory.

Ask which relief is being requested from which agency, what deadline applies, and what legal basis supports any request to excuse lateness. Separate the U visa petition, any necessary waiver and the request to reopen. A favorable development in one does not automatically resolve the others.

Do not wait for another agency to respond before seeking advice about a court deadline. If a filing has already been denied, have the complete motion and the denial reviewed promptly. The practical lesson is careful presentation and careful review of the reasons given, not an assurance of a particular outcome.

SOURCES & FURTHER READING
  1. Seventh Circuit: Panton v. Blanche, No. 25-2528, November 10, 2026 — full published opinion, official court copy via GovInfo
  2. EOIR: Sources of immigration law and the geographic authority of circuit decisions

Source materials were consulted for this original article. Links lead to external resources; later changes may affect the information discussed here.

Attorney Advertising. General information as of November 18, 2026; not legal advice or a prediction of results. Eligibility and strategy require review of your individual circumstances. Read our Legal Disclaimer.

WhatsApp